Skip to content

Validation status

English | Japanese

« Home

This lists the level at which each case is validated. The table is meant to show depth rather than breadth, so cases with only a single-point comparison and cases not yet measured are listed rather than hidden.

tier meaning
T0 Against an analytic solution with evidence of grid convergence (EOC / refinement test)
T1 Automatic gate (ctest) against published reference values
T2 Single-point comparison with published reference values (no automatic gate)
T3 Demo / qualitative check only

gate column: ✅ = the benchmark itself is gated directly · 🧩 = the underlying physics module is gated (the benchmark itself is not run directly) · — = no gate.

The percentages in the "status" column are relative errors against the values published in the original literature. They are not the degree of agreement with other solvers.

category target tier QoI original reference status gate
amr-numerics orheo-acoustic-pulse2d T0 sound_speed analytic acoustic pulse, c_s = 1/sqrt(3) not measured —
laminar orheo-couette-d3q19 T0 velocity-L2-error(abs) analytic linear Couette profile 0.00% —
laminar orheo-poiseuille-d3q19 T0 velocity-L2-error(abs) analytic Hagen-Poiseuille parabola (2nd-order EOC) 0.03% —
laminar orheo-taylor-couette2d T0 velocity-L2-error(abs) analytic Couette solution u_theta = A r + B/r not measured —
optimization-uq orheo-adjoint-poiseuille2d T0 gradient_error discrete adjoint gradient vs finite differences not measured —
optimization-uq orheo-param-id-poiseuille2d T0 recovered_nu recover nu from an observed profile (inverse probl 0.00% —
optimization-uq orheo-uq-poiseuille2d T0 qoi_mean, qoi_std forward UQ: MC vs quadrature pushforward of the ex not measured —
transport orheo-advection-diffusion2d T0 temperature-L2-error(abs) analytic Gaussian Green's function of the AD equat 0.18% 🧩
turbulence orheo-tgv2d-d3q19 T0 ke_decay_rate analytic 2D Taylor-Green decay exp(-2 nu k^2 t) 0.03% —
electrochemistry orheo-electroosmosis2d T1 velocity-L2-error(abs) Helmholtz-Smoluchowski slip velocity not measured 🧩
laminar orheo-cavity3d-d3q27 T1 u_min_centerline Ghia et al. (1982) not measured ✅
laminar orheo-porous-poiseuille2d T1 velocity-L2-error(abs) analytic Brinkman channel solution not measured 🧩
laminar orheo-powerlaw-poiseuille2d T1 velocity-L2-error(abs) analytic Ostwald-de Waele power-law channel profil not measured 🧩
multi-fidelity orheo-expansion-loss2d T1 reattachment_length Armaly et al. (1983) J.Fluid Mech 127:473 -- reatt not measured ✅
multi-fidelity orheo-mf-tee2d T1 — — not measured ✅
multi-fidelity orheo-mf-zonal2d T1 — — not measured ✅
multi-fidelity orheo-multifidelity-duct T1 — — not measured ✅
multiphase orheo-rayleigh-plateau3d T1 — — not measured ✅
thermal orheo-gallium-melting2d T1 melt_front Gau & Viskanta (1986) J.Heat Transfer 108:174 not measured 🧩
thermal orheo-rayleigh-benard2d T1 Nu Clever & Busse (1974) critical Ra=1708 not measured 🧩
thermal orheo-stefan-melting2d T1 front_position analytic one-phase Stefan similarity solution not measured 🧩
thermal orheo-thermal-cavity2d T1 Nu, u_max de Vahl Davis (1983) Int.J.Numer.Meth.Fluids 3:249 0.05% 🧩
transport orheo-graetz2d T1 — — not measured ✅
transport orheo-radiative-transfer2d T1 intensity analytic solutions of the radiative transfer equat not measured 🧩
amr-numerics orheo-forest-dynamic-vortex T2 Vortex retention and tracking Lamb vortex (qualitative) not measured —
amr-numerics orheo-forest-vortex-interface T2 interface_noise Astoul et al. (2020) coarse/fine interface spuriou not measured —
electrochemistry orheo-pnp-full2d T2 edl_profile Gouy-Chapman EDL profile not measured 🧩
external-aero orheo-ahmed-body T2 Cd, Ux(z) ERCOFTAC case082 (Ahmed 25°), Cd~0.285 not measured —
external-aero orheo-airfoil2d T2 — — not measured ✅
external-aero orheo-forest-ahmed-body T2 Cd ERCOFTAC case082 (Ahmed 25°) not measured —
external-aero orheo-forest-ahmed-d3q27 T2 Cd (stability PoC) ERCOFTAC case082 11.23% —
external-aero orheo-forest-aij-d3q27 T2 Vertical wind-speed profile AIJ Case A not measured —
external-aero orheo-forest-building T2 velocity_profile AIJ guidebook Case A/B (Tominaga et al. 2008) not measured —
external-aero orheo-forest-cube-canopy T2 Velocity profile inside the canopy Coceal et al. (2006) DNS not measured —
external-aero orheo-forest-square T2 St, Cd Lyn et al. (1995): St~0.132, Cd~2.1 not measured —
external-aero wall-mounted-cube T2 X_R/H, U/U_b, Reynolds stresses ERCOFTAC case 41 (Martinuzzi & Tropea, LDA), X_R/H~1.62; grid study H/16-H/64 15.4% —
free-surface orheo-forest-koshizuka-dynamic T2 z/a, b/2a Koshizuka & Oka (1996) not measured 🧩
free-surface orheo-forest-koshizuka-dynamic-mixed T2 z/a, b/2a, mass drift Koshizuka & Oka (1996) not measured 🧩
free-surface orheo-forest-koshizuka-mixed T2 z/a, b/2a, seam residual Koshizuka & Oka (1996) not measured 🧩
free-surface orheo-forest-spheric-dyn-mixed T2 P1-P4, H1-H4 Kleefsman et al. (2005) / MARIN not measured —
free-surface orheo-koshizuka T2 z/a, b/2a Koshizuka & Oka (1996) not measured 🧩
free-surface orheo-koshizuka-fs T2 z/a, b/2a Koshizuka & Oka (1996) not measured 🧩
free-surface orheo-koshizuka-fs-d3q27 T2 z/a, b/2a Koshizuka & Oka (1996) not measured 🧩
free-surface orheo-spheric-test2 T2 P1-P4, H1-H4 Kleefsman et al. (2005) / MARIN not measured —
free-surface orheo-spheric-test2-fs T2 P1-P4, H1-H4 Kleefsman et al. (2005) / MARIN not measured 🧩
laminar orheo-bench-ghia1000 T2 u_min_centerline Ghia, Ghia & Shin (1982) J.Comput.Phys 48:387 -- R 1.80% —
laminar orheo-cavity-d3q19 T2 u_min_centerline Ghia et al. (1982) not measured —
laminar orheo-cylinder2d-d3q19 T2 drag, lift, pressureDrop Schaefer & Turek (1996) DFG benchmark 2D-1 (Re=20, 7.55% —
laminar orheo-fda-nozzle3d T2 throat_velocity, pressure_recovery FDA benchmark nozzle (Hariharan et al. 2011) not measured —
laminar orheo-forest-aneurysm T2 wss_dome_over_parent, osi_dome Malek (1999) not measured —
laminar orheo-forest-cylinder-st T2 drag, lift, St Schaefer & Turek (1996) not measured —
laminar orheo-forest-sphere T2 Cd Schiller-Naumann / Clift-Gauvin not measured —
laminar orheo-kbc-cavity2d T2 Centreline u(y), stability limit Ghia et al. (1982) not measured —
laminar orheo-sphere-drag T2 Cd Clift-Gauvin correlation, Re=100 -> Cd~1.09 1.95% —
laminar orheo-venturi3d T2 discharge_coefficient Bernoulli + Borda-Carnot not measured —
multiphase orheo-contact-angle2d T2 contact_angle Young's law cos(theta) = (sigma_sv - sigma_sl)/sig not measured 🧩
multiphase orheo-microfluidics-tjunction2d T2 droplet_length Garstecki et al. (2006) Lab Chip 6:437 squeezing l not measured 🧩
multiphase orheo-phase-separation2d T2 domain_length_exponent spinodal-decomposition coarsening power law L(t) ~ not measured 🧩
multiphase orheo-rayleigh-taylor2d T2 spike_position, bubble_position He, Chen & Zhang (1999) single-mode RT front posit not measured 🧩
multiphase orheo-rising-bubble2d T2 rise_velocity, circularity Hysing et al. (2009) Int.J.Numer.Meth.Fluids 60:12 not measured 🧩
particles-fsi orheo-bifurcation-deposition3d T2 deposition_efficiency Comer, Kleinstreuer & Zhong (2001) bifurcation dep not measured —
particles-fsi orheo-dkt2d T2 dkt_timings Feng, Hu & Joseph (1994) drafting-kissing-tumbling not measured 🧩
particles-fsi orheo-hindered-settling2d T2 settling_ratio Richardson & Zaki (1954) hindered-settling exponen not measured 🧩
particles-fsi orheo-magnetic-particles2d T2 Migration trajectory Point-dipole force + Stokes drag (analytic) not measured —
particles-fsi orheo-sediment-shields2d T2 Critical Shields number theta Shields (1936) threshold-of-motion curve not measured 🧩
particles-fsi orheo-settling-sphere3d T2 terminal_velocity Ten Cate et al. (2002) Phys.Fluids 14:4012 settlin not measured 🧩
particles-fsi orheo-valve-flap2d T2 flap_angle quasi-static torque balance of a hinged flap not measured 🧩
transport orheo-reaction-diffusion2d T2 dispersion_coefficient Taylor-Aris dispersion (Taylor 1953 0.03% 🧩
turbulence orheo-channel3d-d3q19 T2 u_plus_log_law, yPlusMax Kim, Moin & Moser (1987) not measured —
turbulence orheo-forest-bfs T2 reattachment_length Kasagi & Matsunaga (1995) -- turbulent BFS Re_h=55 not measured —
turbulence orheo-forest-channel-d3q27 T2 u+ log law Kim-Moin-Moser (1987) / Moser (1999) not measured —
turbulence orheo-forest-channel-forced-d3q27 T2 Steady nu u''+G=0 profile Analytic solution not measured —
turbulence orheo-kbc-cube-d3q27 T2 Cd, recirculation length L_r/h Wall-mounted cube (qualitative comparison with lit not measured —
turbulence orheo-kbc-tgv3d T2 Dissipation rate eps(t) Brachet (1983) / van Rees (2011) DNS not measured —
turbulence orheo-khi-d3q19 T2 vorticity_structure Minion & Brown (1997) shear-layer roll-up not measured —
turbulence orheo-tgv3d-d3q19 T2 dissipation_rate Brachet et al. (1983) 0.80% —
external-aero drivaer (branch drivaer) T3 reverse-flow length, wake u OpenFOAM simpleFoam k-omega SST of the training course (no published reference) not measured —
external-aero orheo-forest-ahmed-dynamic T3 regrid stability of Cd ERCOFTAC case082 (qualitative) not measured —
free-surface orheo-dam-break T3 Interface shape (qualitative) Koshizuka & Oka (1996) (qualitative comparison) not measured —
free-surface orheo-falling-drop2d T3 — — not measured ✅
laminar orheo-forest-stl T3 Cd (identity of the STL path) Judged by byte-identity with forest_sphere not measured —