Validation status¶
英語 | 日本語
各ケースがどの水準で検証されているかを一覧します。幅よりも深さが分かることを 目的にした表なので、単一点照合しかないケースや未計測のケースも隠さず載せています。
| tier | 意味 |
|---|---|
| T0 | 解析解に対して格子収束の証拠つき(EOC / 細分化試験) |
| T1 | 公表基準値に対する自動ゲート(ctest)あり |
| T2 | 公表基準値との単一点照合(自動ゲートなし) |
| T3 | デモ・定性確認のみ |
gate 列: ✅ = ベンチマーク実体を直接ゲート · 🧩 = 背後の物理モジュールをゲート (ベンチマーク実体は直接には走らない)· — = ゲートなし。
「現状」列の百分率は、原著文献の公表値に対する相対誤差です。他ソルバとの 一致度ではありません。
| category | target | tier | QoI | 原著リファレンス | 現状 | gate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| amr-numerics | orheo-acoustic-pulse2d |
T0 | sound_speed | analytic acoustic pulse, c_s = 1/sqrt(3) | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-couette-d3q19 |
T0 | velocity-L2-error(abs) | analytic linear Couette profile | 0.00% | — |
| laminar | orheo-poiseuille-d3q19 |
T0 | velocity-L2-error(abs) | analytic Hagen-Poiseuille parabola (2nd-order EOC) | 0.03% | — |
| laminar | orheo-taylor-couette2d |
T0 | velocity-L2-error(abs) | analytic Couette solution u_theta = A r + B/r | 未計測 | — |
| optimization-uq | orheo-adjoint-poiseuille2d |
T0 | gradient_error | discrete adjoint gradient vs finite differences | 未計測 | — |
| optimization-uq | orheo-param-id-poiseuille2d |
T0 | recovered_nu | recover nu from an observed profile (inverse probl | 0.00% | — |
| optimization-uq | orheo-uq-poiseuille2d |
T0 | qoi_mean, qoi_std | forward UQ: MC vs quadrature pushforward of the ex | 未計測 | — |
| transport | orheo-advection-diffusion2d |
T0 | temperature-L2-error(abs) | analytic Gaussian Green's function of the AD equat | 0.18% | 🧩 |
| turbulence | orheo-tgv2d-d3q19 |
T0 | ke_decay_rate | analytic 2D Taylor-Green decay exp(-2 nu k^2 t) | 0.03% | — |
| electrochemistry | orheo-electroosmosis2d |
T1 | velocity-L2-error(abs) | Helmholtz-Smoluchowski slip velocity | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| laminar | orheo-cavity3d-d3q27 |
T1 | u_min_centerline | Ghia et al. (1982) | 未計測 | ✅ |
| laminar | orheo-porous-poiseuille2d |
T1 | velocity-L2-error(abs) | analytic Brinkman channel solution | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| laminar | orheo-powerlaw-poiseuille2d |
T1 | velocity-L2-error(abs) | analytic Ostwald-de Waele power-law channel profil | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| multi-fidelity | orheo-expansion-loss2d |
T1 | reattachment_length | Armaly et al. (1983) J.Fluid Mech 127:473 -- reatt | 未計測 | ✅ |
| multi-fidelity | orheo-mf-tee2d |
T1 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| multi-fidelity | orheo-mf-zonal2d |
T1 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| multi-fidelity | orheo-multifidelity-duct |
T1 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| multiphase | orheo-rayleigh-plateau3d |
T1 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| thermal | orheo-gallium-melting2d |
T1 | melt_front | Gau & Viskanta (1986) J.Heat Transfer 108:174 | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| thermal | orheo-rayleigh-benard2d |
T1 | Nu | Clever & Busse (1974) critical Ra=1708 | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| thermal | orheo-stefan-melting2d |
T1 | front_position | analytic one-phase Stefan similarity solution | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| thermal | orheo-thermal-cavity2d |
T1 | Nu, u_max | de Vahl Davis (1983) Int.J.Numer.Meth.Fluids 3:249 | 0.05% | 🧩 |
| transport | orheo-graetz2d |
T1 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| transport | orheo-radiative-transfer2d |
T1 | intensity | analytic solutions of the radiative transfer equat | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| amr-numerics | orheo-forest-dynamic-vortex |
T2 | 渦の保持・追従 | Lamb 渦(定性) | 未計測 | — |
| amr-numerics | orheo-forest-vortex-interface |
T2 | interface_noise | Astoul et al. (2020) coarse/fine interface spuriou | 未計測 | — |
| electrochemistry | orheo-pnp-full2d |
T2 | edl_profile | Gouy-Chapman EDL profile | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| external-aero | orheo-ahmed-body |
T2 | Cd, Ux(z) | ERCOFTAC case082 (Ahmed 25°), Cd~0.285 | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | orheo-airfoil2d |
T2 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-ahmed-body |
T2 | Cd | ERCOFTAC case082 (Ahmed 25°) | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-ahmed-d3q27 |
T2 | Cd(安定性 PoC) | ERCOFTAC case082 | 11.23% | — |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-aij-d3q27 |
T2 | 鉛直風速プロファイル | AIJ Case A | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-building |
T2 | velocity_profile | AIJ guidebook Case A/B (Tominaga et al. 2008) | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-cube-canopy |
T2 | キャノピー内速度プロファイル | Coceal et al. (2006) DNS | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-square |
T2 | St, Cd | Lyn et al. (1995): St~0.132, Cd~2.1 | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | wall-mounted-cube |
T2 | X_R/H、U/U_b、レイノルズ応力 | ERCOFTAC case 41(Martinuzzi & Tropea、LDA)、X_R/H~1.62。格子 H/16〜H/64 | 15.4% | — |
| free-surface | orheo-forest-koshizuka-dynamic |
T2 | z/a, b/2a | Koshizuka & Oka (1996) | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| free-surface | orheo-forest-koshizuka-dynamic-mixed |
T2 | z/a, b/2a, 質量ドリフト | Koshizuka & Oka (1996) | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| free-surface | orheo-forest-koshizuka-mixed |
T2 | z/a, b/2a, seam residual | Koshizuka & Oka (1996) | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| free-surface | orheo-forest-spheric-dyn-mixed |
T2 | P1-P4, H1-H4 | Kleefsman et al. (2005) / MARIN | 未計測 | — |
| free-surface | orheo-koshizuka |
T2 | z/a, b/2a | Koshizuka & Oka (1996) | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| free-surface | orheo-koshizuka-fs |
T2 | z/a, b/2a | Koshizuka & Oka (1996) | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| free-surface | orheo-koshizuka-fs-d3q27 |
T2 | z/a, b/2a | Koshizuka & Oka (1996) | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| free-surface | orheo-spheric-test2 |
T2 | P1-P4, H1-H4 | Kleefsman et al. (2005) / MARIN | 未計測 | — |
| free-surface | orheo-spheric-test2-fs |
T2 | P1-P4, H1-H4 | Kleefsman et al. (2005) / MARIN | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| laminar | orheo-bench-ghia1000 |
T2 | u_min_centerline | Ghia, Ghia & Shin (1982) J.Comput.Phys 48:387 -- R | 1.80% | — |
| laminar | orheo-cavity-d3q19 |
T2 | u_min_centerline | Ghia et al. (1982) | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-cylinder2d-d3q19 |
T2 | drag, lift, pressureDrop | Schaefer & Turek (1996) DFG benchmark 2D-1 (Re=20, | 7.55% | — |
| laminar | orheo-fda-nozzle3d |
T2 | throat_velocity, pressure_recovery | FDA benchmark nozzle (Hariharan et al. 2011) | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-forest-aneurysm |
T2 | wss_dome_over_parent, osi_dome | Malek (1999) | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-forest-cylinder-st |
T2 | drag, lift, St | Schaefer & Turek (1996) | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-forest-sphere |
T2 | Cd | Schiller-Naumann / Clift-Gauvin | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-kbc-cavity2d |
T2 | 中心線 u(y), 安定限界 | Ghia et al. (1982) | 未計測 | — |
| laminar | orheo-sphere-drag |
T2 | Cd | Clift-Gauvin 相関, Re=100 -> Cd~1.09 | 1.95% | — |
| laminar | orheo-venturi3d |
T2 | discharge_coefficient | Bernoulli + Borda-Carnot | 未計測 | — |
| multiphase | orheo-contact-angle2d |
T2 | contact_angle | Young's law cos(theta) = (sigma_sv - sigma_sl)/sig | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| multiphase | orheo-microfluidics-tjunction2d |
T2 | droplet_length | Garstecki et al. (2006) Lab Chip 6:437 squeezing l | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| multiphase | orheo-phase-separation2d |
T2 | domain_length_exponent | spinodal-decomposition coarsening power law L(t) ~ | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| multiphase | orheo-rayleigh-taylor2d |
T2 | spike_position, bubble_position | He, Chen & Zhang (1999) single-mode RT front posit | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| multiphase | orheo-rising-bubble2d |
T2 | rise_velocity, circularity | Hysing et al. (2009) Int.J.Numer.Meth.Fluids 60:12 | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| particles-fsi | orheo-bifurcation-deposition3d |
T2 | deposition_efficiency | Comer, Kleinstreuer & Zhong (2001) bifurcation dep | 未計測 | — |
| particles-fsi | orheo-dkt2d |
T2 | dkt_timings | Feng, Hu & Joseph (1994) drafting-kissing-tumbling | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| particles-fsi | orheo-hindered-settling2d |
T2 | settling_ratio | Richardson & Zaki (1954) hindered-settling exponen | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| particles-fsi | orheo-magnetic-particles2d |
T2 | 泳動軌跡 | 点双極子力 + Stokes 抗力(解析) | 未計測 | — |
| particles-fsi | orheo-sediment-shields2d |
T2 | 限界 Shields 数 theta | Shields (1936) 移動限界曲線 | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| particles-fsi | orheo-settling-sphere3d |
T2 | terminal_velocity | Ten Cate et al. (2002) Phys.Fluids 14:4012 settlin | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| particles-fsi | orheo-valve-flap2d |
T2 | flap_angle | quasi-static torque balance of a hinged flap | 未計測 | 🧩 |
| transport | orheo-reaction-diffusion2d |
T2 | dispersion_coefficient | Taylor-Aris dispersion (Taylor 1953 | 0.03% | 🧩 |
| turbulence | orheo-channel3d-d3q19 |
T2 | u_plus_log_law, yPlusMax | Kim, Moin & Moser (1987) | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-forest-bfs |
T2 | reattachment_length | Kasagi & Matsunaga (1995) -- turbulent BFS Re_h=55 | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-forest-channel-d3q27 |
T2 | u+ 対数則 | Kim-Moin-Moser (1987) / Moser (1999) | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-forest-channel-forced-d3q27 |
T2 | 定常 nu u''+G=0 分布 | 解析解 | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-kbc-cube-d3q27 |
T2 | Cd, 再循環長 L_r/h | 壁面設置立方体(文献値と定性比較) | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-kbc-tgv3d |
T2 | 散逸率 eps(t) | Brachet (1983) / van Rees (2011) DNS | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-khi-d3q19 |
T2 | vorticity_structure | Minion & Brown (1997) shear-layer roll-up | 未計測 | — |
| turbulence | orheo-tgv3d-d3q19 |
T2 | dissipation_rate | Brachet et al. (1983) | 0.80% | — |
| external-aero | drivaer(ブランチ drivaer) |
T3 | 逆流長さ、後流の u | 講習会の OpenFOAM(simpleFoam、k-ω SST)(公表値なし) | 未計測 | — |
| external-aero | orheo-forest-ahmed-dynamic |
T3 | Cd の regrid 安定性 | ERCOFTAC case082(定性) | 未計測 | — |
| free-surface | orheo-dam-break |
T3 | 界面形状(定性) | Koshizuka & Oka (1996)(定性比較) | 未計測 | — |
| free-surface | orheo-falling-drop2d |
T3 | — | — | 未計測 | ✅ |
| laminar | orheo-forest-stl |
T3 | Cd(STL 経路の同一性) | forest_sphere とバイト一致で判定 | 未計測 | — |