コンテンツにスキップ

Cross-code comparison

英語 | 日本語

« Home

機能と検証ケースの有無を他コードと並べた表は LBM の機能比較表 にある。

以下の表は scripts/compare_external.py が生成する英語の報告をそのまま取り込んだもの。† は今回の比較実行で得た値ではない(先行 sweep、または別条件の実行)。同一条件で並べた数字ではないので、そのまま優劣として読まないこと。

Cross-code comparison — OpenRheo vs the external LBM galleries

Generated by scripts/compare_external.py. Each row runs OpenRheo's own benchmark and places its result beside what an external code computed for the same problem — but both are judged against the ORIGINAL published reference, not against each other: two LBM codes agreeing proves nothing if they share a modelling error.

Licensing. OpenLB (GPLv2), Palabos (AGPLv3), waLBerla (GPLv3) and FluidX3D (non-commercial) are incompatible with OpenRheo's Apache-2.0. No line of their source is read or ported. Only facts are used: which cases exist, the numbers their runs printed, and published benchmark values. Every OpenRheo solver here is clean-room from the cited paper.

case QoI OpenRheo published reference rel. err external code
✅ cavity_ghia min of the vertical-centreline u_x/U_lid -0.376 -0.3829 — Ghia, Ghia & Shin (1982), Re=1000 1.80% openlb -0.3693 †, palabos -0.3755 †
✅ couette L2 error of u(z) vs the exact linear profile 1.556e-07 analytic Couette profile 0.00% walberla (not run)
✅ cylinder_st_cd Cd_max (DFG 2D-2, Re=100, unsteady) 3.474 3.23 — Schaefer & Turek (1996) DFG 2D-2, Cd_max = 3.22-3.24 7.55% openlb 5.821, openlb 5.591
✅ cylinder_st_strouhal Strouhal number (DFG 2D-2, Re=100) 0.2982 0.3 — Schaefer & Turek (1996) DFG 2D-2, St = 0.295-0.305 0.60% —
✅ poiseuille_eoc L2 error of u(z) vs the exact parabola 0.0003181 analytic Hagen-Poiseuille parabola 0.03% openlb 0.001177
✅ sphere_drag drag coefficient of a sphere at Re=100 1.111 1.09 — Clift-Gauvin correlation, Re=100 1.95% walberla (not run)
✅ tgv3d peak dissipation rate eps(t), Re=1600 0.0124 0.0125 — Brachet (1983) / van Rees (2011) DNS Re=1600, peak eps ~ 1.25e-2 0.80% openlb 0.009248
✅ thermal_cavity Nusselt number at the hot wall, Ra=1e4 2.244 2.243 — de Vahl Davis (1983), Ra=1e4 Nu = 2.243 0.05% openlb 1.104 † (different Ra)

Notes per case:

  • cavity_ghia — driven runs: OpenLB -0.3693, Palabos -0.3755 (this session's earlier sweep)
  • couette — waLBerla ships the case but it was not run here
  • cylinder_st_cd — OpenLB ran the OTHER benchmark (2D-1, Re=20): its 5.82 is vs the 5.58 2D-1 reference, NOT comparable to our 2D-2 number
  • cylinder_st_strouhal — OpenLB's steady 2D-1 run has no shedding frequency to compare
  • poiseuille_eoc — OpenLB prints the same L2 norm
  • sphere_drag — waLBerla ships the case but it was not run here
  • tgv3d — OpenLB Turbulence_Dissipation_Rate.dat (last row, not necessarily the peak)
  • thermal_cavity — OpenLB ran Ra=1e6-class settings (Nu 1.104 at its own Ra) -- not the same Ra, quoted for context only

Legend: ✅ within tolerance of the published value · ⚠️ ran but outside tolerance · ❌ did not produce the QoI · † = not obtained in this comparison run (an earlier sweep, or a run at other settings). These numbers were not produced under identical conditions, so do not read them as a ranking. Logs: _agent_out/xcompare/*.log (written by scripts/compare_external.py when run).

ライセンスについて(clean-room)

OpenRheo は Apache-2.0 です。OpenLB (GPLv2) / Palabos (AGPLv3) / waLBerla (GPLv3) / FluidX3D(非商用)はいずれもライセンス非互換であり、 それらのソースコードは一切読まず、移植もしていません。利用しているのは 「どのケースが存在するか」という事実と、各ケースの原著論文が公表している 基準値だけです。本ギャラリーの各ソルバは原著論文からクリーンルームで実装され、 判定は常に原著文献に対して行います(他コードの出力に合わせることはしません)。